Last week a promotional video was released online by The Bible Society featuring two Liberal Party MPs discussing gay marriage while drinking Coopers Light Ale. The video titled "Keeping it Light" sparked a backlash against Coopers, though the Bible Society has stated that the brewery had nothing to do with the content.
The
first I heard of Coopersgate from everyone’s best mate Graham Richardson in The Australian. Richo reckons that the big Gay/Green
hissy fit and threat of a boycott of Coopers beer was “blind
insistence against free speech” and “cruel as it was
anti-democratic.”
Cruel,
my word – but was the Cooper family denied their right to free
speech? No. Quite the opposite in fact. They were given a free public
platform where they could have exercised the hell out of free speech.
We would have hung on every word. They just decided that the profits
from selling beer are more important than going to the mattresses
over marriage equality. And good luck to them.
Anti-democratic?
No way. Democracy is a system where citizens elect representatives to
form a government. Not under attack here, Richo.
Over
on page 12 the delectable Jennifer Oriel (my current conservative
crush) jumped aboard the freedom train under a heading of Gay censors don't want us thinking for ourselves and talked about a
“grim week for freedom of expression”.
She
did go on, however, to nail the issue squirmingly to the wall,
“ In
their campaign for gay marriage, some activists have developed a
regrettably totalitarian strategy. It is to target dissenters, gay or
straight, and silence them through persistent bullying.
They dislike civility and public reason because it exposes their intemperance.
… the video celebrated public reason on the question of marriage, which is an issue the PC class wants to monopolise. It targets dissenters, regardless of whether they are gay, bisexual or straight. The aim is to shut down all debate to create absolute ideological conformity.”
They dislike civility and public reason because it exposes their intemperance.
… the video celebrated public reason on the question of marriage, which is an issue the PC class wants to monopolise. It targets dissenters, regardless of whether they are gay, bisexual or straight. The aim is to shut down all debate to create absolute ideological conformity.”
I
agree (and I love your hair). But until the activists actually succeed in their aims to shut down all debate - this story is about
bigotry and bullying.
Bigotry
(intolerance towards those holding different
opinions) is lawful in Australia and
does not necessarily affect freedom of speech. A bigot's mind is
closed to the speech of others. In a totalitarian state a bigot might
achieve a position of power and use the forces of the state to
silence dissenters. But Australia is not such a place.
Bullying
is something we forbid in schools, regulate in workplaces but
encourage in politics. Bullies are often admired for their ability to
get shit done. Kevin Rudd was a notorious bully who became Prime
Minister (twice). Mark Latham, Peta Credlin and Tony Abbott - all
highly successful bullies. Outside of the schoolyard and the
workplace – you can lawfully bully the hell out of all and sundry
so long as you cause no physical harm to your victims.
The gay
activists were exercising their lawful freedoms of expression and
action whether we like it or not. They can use such freedom to
campaign for or against anything they please. And so can you, so can
we.
Bullies always pick the softest target - so Coopers Brewery became the focus of the attack because Liberal MPs and religious organisations are too hard to get to. Coopers however is a public company that relies on retailers to sell their product to the public making them susceptible to a boycott.
However, freedom of speech triumphs in the end by giving these bigots plenty of rope with which to hang themselves. In this case - the activists' actions will harden the hearts of the conservatives they should be wooing. They will alienate gay allies such as Liberal MP Tim Wilson who appeared in the video as an advocate of marriage equality.
And
they alienate me.
And
that matters because I am for marriage equality too – but simply
because I cannot insist on freedom for myself but not for others.
That would make me a hypocrite and no-one would take me seriously. As a libertarian I
have to champion marriage equality and I will – but the intolerant
shrieking of pack of bigoted bullying bastards ain't making it any
easier.
As a libertarian I am seriously attempting to frame important issues from a
perspective that is not Left or Right, that eschews identity and
instead looks for common ground between warring parties. That common
ground is freedom. I seek to persuade you that the irresistible force
of freedom just might be able to shift some seemingly immovable objects. I do this by
writing my most persuasive arguments in this blog – not by pissing in your beer.
If
the hearts and minds of conservative people and politicians must be
won for gay marriage to pass – then so be it. Bullying and beer
boycotts will not persuade them - it will push them further away.
Instead,
try inviting them aboard the freedom train (I'm sitting next to
Jennifer).
No comments:
Post a Comment